We had a case of Outraging Public Decency in the other day - not an everyday occurrence in my court. A rather unsavoury looking woman of 22 admitted having full-on sex with a man on public transport, in full view of other passengers at eight in the morning. For some reason the man concerned had been dealt with a couple of weeks ago, so it seemed fair to give her the same sentence.
There is no specific guideline for this so we took a cue from that for Sexual Activity in a Public Lavatory, namely a fine. She had spent two days in custody, so we deemed the fine and surcharge served.
Musings and Snippets from a recently retired JP. I served for 31 years, mostly in west London. I was Chairman of my Bench for some years, and a member of the National Bench Chairmen's Forum All cases are based on real ones, but anonymised and composited. All opinions are those of one or more individuals. JPs swear to enforce the law of the land, whether or not they approve of it. Nothing on here constitutes legal advice.
Wednesday, April 15, 2015
What's Going On At The MA?
The Magistrates' Association has puzzled a few of us in recent weeks. I have been a member for about 30 years, dutifully coughing up thirty-odd quid each year. In recent years the MA website Members' Section has included a (passworded) forum. It has never attracted many contributors, but I have chipped in occasionally, as have luminaries such as Richard Monkhouse, the MA Chairman. Now, it has simply vanished, without any notice to readers and contributors nor any explanation as to why. My passwords for the Members' Section are now rejected.
This seems a shabby way to treat paid-up members. I cannot see that the Forum did any harm to anyone, after all.
Forum software is cheap and plentiful, so perhaps someone will set up a site where JPs can talk to each other and compare notes without fear of being got at by the tabloids.
This seems a shabby way to treat paid-up members. I cannot see that the Forum did any harm to anyone, after all.
Forum software is cheap and plentiful, so perhaps someone will set up a site where JPs can talk to each other and compare notes without fear of being got at by the tabloids.
Monday, April 13, 2015
On a Personal Note
Saturday's Boat Race (s) and tonight's University Challenge remind me of my 1950s childhood in the school playground. Menacing groups of lads (ignorant to a man of anything to do with universities) would question you whether you supported the dark or the light Blues. The 'wrong' answer would be punished. For whatever reason I supported Oxford.
Many years later my dear daughter got into Cambridge where she met my son-in-law. They married in the College Chapel, so I have to admit that I have changed my alliegance.
It doesn't mean a thing really. but it shows how small things can create loyalties.
Many years later my dear daughter got into Cambridge where she met my son-in-law. They married in the College Chapel, so I have to admit that I have changed my alliegance.
It doesn't mean a thing really. but it shows how small things can create loyalties.
Wednesday, April 08, 2015
How Much Did That Cost?
(From Bystander N)
I recently spent time in a
crown court’s public gallery. I’m used
to being on the bench with a judge or recorder, but not elsewhere in the court
room.
My first two impressions were
not favourable. Much of the seating used
by the advocates was ripped or badly worn and held together with masking
tape. The proceedings started about
forty minutes late mainly because the prosecutor needed time to copy a summary
for the jurors. Why, I asked myself,
wasn’t this done before the start of the trial?
The offence was sexual
assault and definitely at the lower end of the scale. A hand was alleged to have cupped a buttock,
over clothing. I was there on day two
and heard that when the alleged victim gave evidence she said she hadn’t felt anything
and hadn’t known an offence had taken place.
A friend who was with her said she had seen it. I heard the defendant being examined and cross
examined. No doubt the judge, in summing
up, would have told the jury that his having no previous made him more
believable than otherwise.
To give just a little of the
background the defendant said the incident started when a small group of
teenagers on his bus seemed to him to be talking about him and laughing at
him. He told them to behave
themselves. Based on his evidence, the
CC TV from which I could not see any offence committed, and what I heard of
what the other witnesses had said I felt the prosecution had not proved its
case beyond a reasonable doubt. I came
away with a question though.
I knew by lunch on day two
that there were three civilian prosecution witnesses, the defendant and the
officer in the case who I also heard give evidence. There were some agreed statements. The officer’s evidence left questions in my
mind over the way they had dealt with it, but I digress. I worked out that if held in my court the
trial should have been set for a day. I
would be surprised if a magistrates’ court had declined jurisdiction and it was
more likely that the defendant, or rather his solicitor, had opted for crown
court.
In those august surroundings,
three days had been allocated. What did
that cost, whoever ended up paying, compared with what it would have cost in my
court? No wonder the justice system is
short of money.
Monday, April 06, 2015
Comments
Comments to this blog are always welcome, and are moderated with a light touch. However I have just had to hold a couple that go into detail of someone's case. Unfortunately the blog is not the place to go over old individual cases. Sorry.
Tuesday, March 31, 2015
Callous and Destructive
This is the latest atrocity to be imposed on the courts by the ministry that calls itself "Justice" with no sense of irony.
Whoever dreamed this scheme up must not only lack any empathy with fragile human beings, but also lack any kind of experience of what day to day life is like in the lower courts, and the rough estates.
Most of our defendants are poor and many are ill-educated and close to unemployable. A high proportion are in receipt of benefits.
Now, in addition to the courts' sanctions we must, without judicial discretion, impose large financial penalties on those who appear before us. We may not take account of ability to pay, which has been an underlying principle for as long as I have been on the bench.
The impositions are unlikely to be collected (Blood/stone principle) and the amount outstanding will rapidly escalate into the multi-millions.
So much for the fine principles of rehabilitation.
When our revolving-door druggy shoplifter is released from his latest prison sentence, along with his release grant he will be handed a bill for potentially hundreds of pounds to pay out of his princely seventy-odd quid a week benefit. What is he likely to do?
Go back to crime, of course.
Simples.
Whoever dreamed this scheme up must not only lack any empathy with fragile human beings, but also lack any kind of experience of what day to day life is like in the lower courts, and the rough estates.
Most of our defendants are poor and many are ill-educated and close to unemployable. A high proportion are in receipt of benefits.
Now, in addition to the courts' sanctions we must, without judicial discretion, impose large financial penalties on those who appear before us. We may not take account of ability to pay, which has been an underlying principle for as long as I have been on the bench.
The impositions are unlikely to be collected (Blood/stone principle) and the amount outstanding will rapidly escalate into the multi-millions.
So much for the fine principles of rehabilitation.
When our revolving-door druggy shoplifter is released from his latest prison sentence, along with his release grant he will be handed a bill for potentially hundreds of pounds to pay out of his princely seventy-odd quid a week benefit. What is he likely to do?
Go back to crime, of course.
Simples.
Sunday, March 29, 2015
More From Bystander N
Magistrates don’t usually
know until arrival what the business will be of the court room we are allocated
to, or who we will be sitting with for the day.
It could be remands, trials, breaches of orders or other work. Recently, for me, it was sentencing.
Over the day we completed our
list of about a dozen or so cases and helped out another busy court with some
of theirs. We agreed with most of the
report recommendations and changed a couple.
At the end of the day I asked
my colleagues if they had noticed anything unusual about the day. They hadn’t and perhaps they were right but
it had struck me that every single one of the reports we had read said that the
defendant had a mental health problem and in several cases we had an extra
report from a mental health team worker.
One offence took place in a hospital in which the defendant and victim had
been admitted as a result of acute mental health problems. In another, and with no extra report, I was
far from convinced it was true but in many cases we didn’t even need the extra
report to recognise the blindingly obvious in front of us.
Probably the most notable,
but in the scheme of things totally unremarkable case was the drug addicted
alcoholic before us who stole a pack of four cans of lager. He got two out of their plastic top cover but
was stopped on leaving the store. He hadn’t
opened any of the cans, they were repacked in the supermarket and put back for
sale, but he was arrested. We had no
idea why the store didn’t just tell him what for and send him on his merry way
but I suspect they knew him of old and had simply had enough. Many shops have a policy of calling the
police when they stop a thief, regardless of the value of what was taken.
He pleaded guilty and
appeared to be sober when we saw him. I
pointed out to him that this would be the ninetieth offence on his record and
you can imagine what most of the previous offences were. He has been to prison many times for
theft. In mitigation we heard that he had
no home and had been an addict for a long time.
His life revolved around going to his chemist for his heroin substitute
prescription, and finding ways to get alcohol.
He looked at least twenty years older than his true age.
He had been arrested almost
twenty four hours before appearing before us so we fined him, deemed it served
as he had no money, and ordered that he be kept in the cells until they closed
later that afternoon. At least he would
then go away having had a meal, back no doubt to hanging around his chemist and
anywhere stocking alcohol. I resisted
the temptation to say goodbye and see you soon, but no doubt I will.
Saturday, March 21, 2015
Told You So
I have previously mentioned Lord Justice Bean, whom I respect and admire. In the past I have had the temerity to predict that he would go on to greater things.
He has now been sworn in to the Privy Council.
Good.
He has now been sworn in to the Privy Council.
Good.
Surprising
This BBC report surprised me and will probably surprise a lot of magistrates. The offence boils down to a potentially vicious attack, in a context of road rage. These factors would led me to expect a serious sentence of at least a year or two, but this disposal appears a bit milk-and-water. Any thoughts?
That Ridiculous Surcharge Again.
(from Bystander N)
I have just been reading the full sentencing remarks of HHJ Pontius
in the matter of R v Brusthom Ziamani, who had planned to cut off the head of a
British soldier. As is usual from a
judge they give a clear and precise explanation for the sentencing decision he
came to.
He said “Formally expressed, therefore, I pass an extended sentence
of twenty seven years, the custodial term of which is twenty two years, with a
licence extension of five years” and his final sentence reads “If a Victim
Surcharge is appropriate in this case the relevant order will be drawn up and
served on the defendant in due course.”
I noticed a card on the bench in my local crown court where I sat this
week with just this wording.
In the magistrates’ courts we have to work out the surcharge and
announce to the defendant what the amount is and then we deal with payment, or
at least we set the terms, and then wonder if they will ever be met, even if
the defendant has agreed them.
The crown court does not always seem to deal with this in detail
but can someone tell me the point, in a case like this, of applying a charge of
£120? Does anyone seriously think it
will ever be paid or will it just be added to the vast number of fines, costs,
compensations and surcharges that don’t happen as the court instructed?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)