Saturday, November 14, 2009

A Blinding Flash of the Obvious

Jack Straw today gave the Mags' Association AGM some advice about collecting fines.

A Grim Reminder

This is a tragic reminder of the responsibility that magistrates carry when they decide to grant or withhold bail. Every bail decision is a calculated risk because there are few certainties. Whether there are 'substantial grounds' to fear further offences, failure to surrender, or interference with witnesses is a judgment call, pure and simple.
The newspaper is unfair in its report, as you would expect: it suggests that the decision was taken by one named JP rather than a bench, "despite" CPS objections. If we always followed the CPS line, nobody would ever get bail and we would need another 50,000 prison places. As I have said before, all that we can do is consider the evidence with great care, stick to the Bail Act rules, and hope that we get it right.

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Short Shrift

So-called 'Mr. Loophole' doesn't always get his clients off, as in this case.

As the Crown Court judge (who was sitting with two JPs) pointed out, the fees of Mr. Freeman probably far exceeded the fines and costs imposed, but for a Premiership footballer it's all small change anyway.

I was interested to see that the DJ in the lower court was 'Custody' Cooper, who seems to crop up in the news quite frequently.

Later - Here's another one who came unstuck.

This Needed Saying

The constant harping on from Government about 'putting victims at the centre of justice' is in danger, as this article points out, of raising false expectations in victims of crime, and of blurring the reality that it is the state that prosecutes and the state that punishes crime, as it must. Anything else is a cruel deception, made to grab a headline.

More of The Same Claptrap

The Sun reports today that the government intends to increase the minimum term of imprisonment for those who murder using a knife. The paper claims this as a 'victory' for its campaign. Here is the Times report.

This is an absolutely typical piece of Straw's Law, and it will be bad law for a number of reasons:-

It will be introduced by Statutory Instrument, bypassing proper Parliamentary scrutiny.

It will be introduced to satisfy a media campaign driven by a prominent case in which the victim was the brother of a TV celebrity.

It takes no account of the fact that every case is different and turns on its own facts.

If it allows, as it should, judges to make exceptions where they think it to be just to do so, it will be meaningless. If not there will be injustice.

It will specify a 25-year starting point for a murder using a knife, but not for an axe, or a chainsaw, or a piece of wood with nails in, or any of the myriad weapons that humans use to maim and kill each other.

It will have not the slightest effect at street level. Someone prepared to risk a 15-year stretch isn't going to pack it in and take up embroidery because the ante has been upped to 25 years.

Hard cases make bad law. They are about to make another one.

Monday, November 09, 2009

The Logjam Starts To Move

Along with many others from all levels of the judiciary I am unhappy about the trend to out-of-court disposals that has led to more than half of all so-called offences brought to justice being dealt with outside a court, by way of a simple or conditional caution, or a fixed penalty of some sort. It has enabled the government to brag, quite fraudulently, that it is bringing more and more offences to 'justice' - but what kind of justice? The Magistrates' Association, which has recently brought a long-overdue vigour and robustness to its campaigning on this topic has managed to push the issue into the public's gaze. Tonight 'Panorama' will deal with the issue (it will be available to watch again online for a week) and there is a selection of informed views
here,
here
here
here
and here.

With the MA, the DPP, the Commissioner of the Met and others joining in, it looks as if the Justice Secretary will have to bow to pressure to bring the extra-judicial juggernaut under control. It must be about five years ago that I sat in a London conference centre listening incredulously to the plans for Conditional Cautions, stitched up behind closed doors by the CPS and the police. I was sitting next to a respected District Judge, and his feelings echoed mine. This was another of the snap judgments that emanated from the Blair sofa at no. 10, and not the first to have been shown to fail. It won't be the last, either.

Sunday, November 08, 2009

Guest Post

I am genuinely honoured to be able to post a guest contribution from the widely respected Glenna Robson, who has contributed to many legal and academic publications.
Her article speaks for itself.
“Must follow” takes pole position

Recently on this blog Peter Hargreaves rightly drew attention to the latest mammoth criminal justice bill to be wending its way through Parliament – the Coroners and Justice Bill. This is an amalgamation of two separate bills signalled in one of those spurious Queen’s Speeches now made in mid-summer by the Prime Minister and which purports to lay out government policy. The Coroners Bill has been around for some time and was heavily criticised in its original form by the Constitutional Affairs Select Committee (now the Justice and formerly the Lord Chancellor’s Select Committee) in its Annual Report for 2005-5. All went quiet during 2007-8 but the Bill resurfaced in 2008 and was again the subject of sharp criticism by the Committee in its intention to limit coroners’ powers. At the same time (June 2008) it was announced that that there would be a separate bill on Law Reform, Victims and Witnesses. Instead, these two bills got rolled into the present hotchpotch which has just received its Third Reading in the Lords (November 5). There are plenty of points for discussion, but for magistrates it is Part 4 which is of particular interest. Therein lie the provisions for abolishing the Sentencing Advisory Panel and the Sentencing Guidelines Council and establishing a Sentencing Council whose guidelines sentencers “must follow”. Currently under the provisions of the CJA 2003 S.172 sentencers are ordered to “have regard to” the guidelines. The Magistrates’ Association as well as the Conservative Party have fought to preserve this latter statutory obligation. Slight amendments in the general wording were won but the MA stated that “they are not strong enough to allay fears that undue influence through a too rigid sentencing structure will be imposed on sentencers”. High hopes were pinned on a possible successful amendment in the Lords. However the former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Woolf, signalled in both the Committee and the Report stages that he felt that there was a clear two-stage process that the sentencer “must follow” the guideline “unless the court is satisfied that it would be contrary to the interests of justice to do so”. The nub of his argument can be found on: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200809/ldhansrd/text/91028-0010.htm
It obviously swayed some who might have voted in favour of the amendment. As it is, the Bill goes back to the Commons and the expectation is that it will be law within days. It is interesting to note that although the Council of Circuit Judges also joined in protests about “must follow”, the senior judiciary have been silent unlike their reaction to the government’s original proposal of a sentencing grid. So will this Bill make guidelines more like tramlines?

Friday, November 06, 2009

Out Of The Mouths Of Babes....

We saw a case of carrying a bladed article a few weeks ago. Most facts were agreed and our job was to decide, on the balance of probabilities, whether the defendant had a reasonable excuse that would amount to a defence. We went out to consider, thinking that the case was pretty finely balanced.
We went through the evidence, and as we were re-reading an interview, one of my colleagues, on her third-ever sitting, spotted a massive inconsistency between the interview and the evidence that our man had just given on oath.
I am not saying that the three of us wouldn't have got there in the end, but one of the strengths of the magistracy is the constant influx of newly trained colleagues who treat every case as a new experience, and with their training fresh in their minds.
Guilty, then.

Wednesday, November 04, 2009

Sadly, No Audrey Hepburn


The confused and confusing state of the sentencing regime is something that every sentencer is aware of. Our training and guidelines insist that the sentence pronounced is indeed the sentence imposed, but there isn't a single member of the judiciary who doesn't know that the whole business can be a charade sometimes.
A few months ago we were faced with a local drunk who had again breached his ASBO. He had spent two nights in police custody, and was represented by a decent, seasoned solicitor of many years' experience. The solicitor accepted that his client was an alcoholic who was unwilling to seek treatment. He pointed out the utter futility of the man's arrest and charge with an offence carrying up to 5 years on indictment. Until half a dozen years ago the man had a house and a job and a family. Now he was derelict and homeless. We were urged to allow his release forthwith, by imposing a fine and deeming it served, but for technical reasons to do with the man's record that wasn't really on. Only custody would be appropriate, but how long? This is where the the guidelines are unhelpful, because of the shambolic early-release system. 21 days means that he would have to serve seven of them before early release could kick in. On the other hand, 28 days, bearing in mind the 3 days that our man would have served already, would result in his early release, certainly in the next few days, possibly sooner. So I went through the pronouncement of a 28 day prison sentence, knowing, as did my colleagues, the clerk, the prosecutor and the defence brief that he would serve nothing like 28 days. I was of course quite unable to announce openly what would really happen and why we were making the order that we did. That's a charade for you.

Here is an explanation of the rules for early release.
This system has already lost the confidence of the press and public and is fast losing the confidence of many sentencers. The new government that we will get next year will have a lot on its plate, but this mess should be high on the agenda for the new Justice Secretary.

Sunday, November 01, 2009

Trouble On The Way

The indispensible CrimeLine reports:-

In Gidden v Chief Constable of Humberside, DC, 29 October 2009 (no transcript available), the court quashed a conviction for speeding. The applicant had been sent, via first class post, a notice of intended prosecution. However, due to postal strikes the NIP did not arrive until 16 days after the offence.

The question posed for the determination of the High Court was whether, upon a proper construction of s.1(1)(c), s.1(1A)(c) and s.1(3) of the Road Traffic Act 1988, a notice of intended prosecution should be regarded as having been properly served where the notice was sent by first class ordinary post on a date that would normally lead to it being delivered within the 14-day time limit but where the court was satisfied that it was actually delivered after the 14-day time limit.

Held: Save for NIP's sent by registered post or recorded delivery, the presumption of delivery was rebuttable. It was not possible to read down the Act, nor the CrPR 2005, to provide for a convenient way to close what may well become a well used loophole.

This seems to have resurrected, thanks to the postal workers' strikes, the long-running Section 172 controversy, in which hundreds of motorists who have been snapped by speed cameras have disputed the validity (especially in respect of what is good service) of the notice of intended prosecution and the requirement to name the driver of the speeding vehicle.
Solicitors who make a living from defending motorists (one of the groups that is most likely to stump up the cost of representation) will be rubbing their hands.