I dealt with a drink-drive case recently that hinged on whether a particular piece of ground was private or public, and, if the former, whether it was ground to which the public has access. This issue often arises in drink-drive offences that take place in pub car parks, and the case law is such that courts nearly always find that such car parks are in fact public places.
In the most recent case counsel had prepared photocopies of various judgements to help us, and one particular case rang a bell in my mind. I read it and I realised that it was a trial that I had sat on. The defendant appealed, and I was quite chuffed to read that the higher court had agreed with the magistrates.
Chatting about the case later, we were reminded of the sad tale of the eldest son of an aristocratic landowning family who had organised a gymkhana and fair on his family's estate. Some way into the day he was driving his Range Rover across a meadow when he stopped to speak to one of the local policemen who were supervising traffic in and out of the site. Eldest Son had taken some champagne with his pals earlier, and he was shocked and indeed furious when one of the officers required him to take a breath test (which he duly failed). Protesting loudly he was taken off to the nearest police station where the evidential machine produced a reading around double the limit.
Solicitors were instructed and the case came before the local bench, by which time learned Counsel had been engaged. The defence hinged on the fact that ES had been driving on his family's land where the Road Traffic Act does not apply. Unfortunately for him, the court found that the fact that the field was being used as a car park by members of the public made it fall within the category of a public place, albeit only for the two days of the event.
So he was convicted, and that conviction was upheld on the subsequent appeal. Summer event time is upon us again, so do be careful even if you think that you are on private land - there could be a nasty surprise in store.
Musings and Snippets from a recently retired JP. I served for 31 years, mostly in west London. I was Chairman of my Bench for some years, and a member of the National Bench Chairmen's Forum All cases are based on real ones, but anonymised and composited. All opinions are those of one or more individuals. JPs swear to enforce the law of the land, whether or not they approve of it. Nothing on here constitutes legal advice.
Wednesday, July 27, 2005
Monday, July 25, 2005
Yet More Bail
I dealt with nine overnight cases the other day, and in each one the only issue was whether or not they were to be granted bail or remanded in custody. The Bail Act provides for a presumption in favour of bail unless there are 'substantial' grounds to fear that the defendant will abscond, commit further offences, or interfere with witnesses. What is 'substantial' is up to the bench and that is why bail decisions are among the real red meat of the magistrate's job.
Some cases were simple. The man who had a huge amount of cocaine (street value north of a quarter-million) and who therefore faces something like ten years, didn't apply for bail as his counsel had presumably told him that he had no chance because of the clear incentive to do a runner. Remanded in custody for a week. At the other end of the scale was a woman of 35 who appeared to be on the edge of being mentally unstable and who had smashed some glasses in her boyfriend's house and then had an unavailing poke at the police when they turned up. She couldn't be sent back to the address, of course, but her worried-looking mum was in court and offered to take her in, so I told her that she would be bailed on condition that she lives and sleeps at mum's place. The 18 year old street robber who had failed to answer bail on two separate mobile phone muggings was refused bail because he is looking at a considerable stretch despite his youth.
The trickiest was another woman of about 40 whose heroin addiction has led her to have a 14 page criminal record, almost all of it for small scale theft and deception. She had been arrested while she was already on bail for two similar offences, and by the book she should have been remanded in custody, for the obvious fear of further offences. She has four children, and is five months pregnant, and that's what clinched it for me. I re-bailed her, avoiding the eye of our resident police officer who was bound to be thinking that I was a soft touch. Perhaps I am, but she is non-violent, does most harm to herself, and I just wasn't prepared to send a pregnant woman to Holloway with the weekend looming.
Her tattooed boyfriend did call out "thank you Sir" as he left, so it's nice to have one satisfied customer at least.
Final score: five bail, four custody.
Some cases were simple. The man who had a huge amount of cocaine (street value north of a quarter-million) and who therefore faces something like ten years, didn't apply for bail as his counsel had presumably told him that he had no chance because of the clear incentive to do a runner. Remanded in custody for a week. At the other end of the scale was a woman of 35 who appeared to be on the edge of being mentally unstable and who had smashed some glasses in her boyfriend's house and then had an unavailing poke at the police when they turned up. She couldn't be sent back to the address, of course, but her worried-looking mum was in court and offered to take her in, so I told her that she would be bailed on condition that she lives and sleeps at mum's place. The 18 year old street robber who had failed to answer bail on two separate mobile phone muggings was refused bail because he is looking at a considerable stretch despite his youth.
The trickiest was another woman of about 40 whose heroin addiction has led her to have a 14 page criminal record, almost all of it for small scale theft and deception. She had been arrested while she was already on bail for two similar offences, and by the book she should have been remanded in custody, for the obvious fear of further offences. She has four children, and is five months pregnant, and that's what clinched it for me. I re-bailed her, avoiding the eye of our resident police officer who was bound to be thinking that I was a soft touch. Perhaps I am, but she is non-violent, does most harm to herself, and I just wasn't prepared to send a pregnant woman to Holloway with the weekend looming.
Her tattooed boyfriend did call out "thank you Sir" as he left, so it's nice to have one satisfied customer at least.
Final score: five bail, four custody.
Saturday, July 23, 2005
Tragic Shooting
I have just read the Met Police statement on the man who was shot by officers yesterday, and it appears that a dreadful mistake has been made. I have nothing to say about the incident - there will be a full enquiry of course, and whatever its findings I am sure that we will all recognise that in the present situation, just as in the earlier Irish conflict, mistakes will happen and innocent people will die.
What does strike me is that the gloating that took place after the event in the press ("One Down Three to Go") and on the Internet, where it was as intemperate as we must expect from this most uninhibited medium, now looks particularly foolish and disgusting.
Yet again, the best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity. This is going to be a very long road, I am afraid.
What does strike me is that the gloating that took place after the event in the press ("One Down Three to Go") and on the Internet, where it was as intemperate as we must expect from this most uninhibited medium, now looks particularly foolish and disgusting.
Yet again, the best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity. This is going to be a very long road, I am afraid.
Friday, July 22, 2005
I'm Flattered - Well, Up To A Point, Anyway
I have just noticed that in a post a few weeks ago, we got a mention in uklawyers legal newswires (by Steve Butler and Joe Reevy) number 55.
They quote the blog header, and say we are 'sometimes entertaining'.
Thanks guys, that's about on a par with the Hitchhikers' Guide to the Galaxy describing earth as 'mostly harmless'.
They quote the blog header, and say we are 'sometimes entertaining'.
Thanks guys, that's about on a par with the Hitchhikers' Guide to the Galaxy describing earth as 'mostly harmless'.
Wednesday, July 20, 2005
Encouraging News
A 15-year-old boy has won a landmark High Court challenge to the legality of child curfew zones used to tackle anti-social behaviour.
The teenager said the use of dispersal zones in Richmond, south-west London, breached his rights under the European Convention on Human Rights.
Unaccompanied under-16s found in zones after 9pm can be held and escorted home, whether badly behaved or not.
The police and Richmond Council argued that it reduced anti-social behaviour.
The High Court ruled that the law did not give the police a power of arrest, and officers could not force someone to come with them.
Lord Justice Brooke said: "... All of us have the right to walk the streets without interference from police constables or CSOs unless they possess common law or statutory powers to stop us.
"If Parliament considered that such a power was needed, it should have said so, and identified the circumstances in which it intended the power to be exercised."
(from BBC News)
This is a poke in the eye for the authoritarians in the Home Office, and it is truly heartening to see one of our most senior judges standing up for the citizen's ancient rights.
The teenager said the use of dispersal zones in Richmond, south-west London, breached his rights under the European Convention on Human Rights.
Unaccompanied under-16s found in zones after 9pm can be held and escorted home, whether badly behaved or not.
The police and Richmond Council argued that it reduced anti-social behaviour.
The High Court ruled that the law did not give the police a power of arrest, and officers could not force someone to come with them.
Lord Justice Brooke said: "... All of us have the right to walk the streets without interference from police constables or CSOs unless they possess common law or statutory powers to stop us.
"If Parliament considered that such a power was needed, it should have said so, and identified the circumstances in which it intended the power to be exercised."
(from BBC News)
This is a poke in the eye for the authoritarians in the Home Office, and it is truly heartening to see one of our most senior judges standing up for the citizen's ancient rights.
Tuesday, July 19, 2005
Now That's What I Call Plucky
We heard a fairly simple trial today about some motoring offences involving drink and a bent motor car with a few other odds and ends that I can't mention without getting too close to giving the game away.
The defendant was represented by a barrister and was what lawyers call (often with discreet smacking of the lips) a 'private payer' so the bill for solicitor and counsel was coming out of his own pocket.
Not to put too fine a point on it, his defence case was a crock of..... no, let decorum reign and let me say that it was not too strong. He had admitted enough to the arresting officers to guarantee his conviction before any bench that I can imagine, and just to make certain he had dotted all of the whatsits and crossed all of the doodahs in a taped interview. Nevertheless, Not Guilty was the plea, as is his right, and an attractive young barrister (yes, the attractive is irrelevant, but I am allowed to notice) made the best of a bad job. To make matters worse for the defence the relatively inexperienced Crown prosecutor had to be elsewhere at short notice so a barrister was drafted in from Chambers. As luck would have it the Chambers clerk had already despatched all of his young tyros so we got, thanks to the cab-rank rule, a fifty-ish brief who had obviously got a lot of legal mileage on his clock.
Following her client's instructions the defending counsel put forward his story, that was both implausible and legally hopeless. She had a polite go at the police officers' evidence, but I really started to admire her when her client went into the box and dug himself even deeper into the mire. She kept her composure, and her closing address to the court was properly researched, impeccable as to case law, and delivered with bright-eyed conviction.
Conviction is what her client got too.
I admire her because faced with one of the worst defence scenarios since the Little Big Horn she did a professional job and carried on fighting for her client until the inevitably bitter end. She knew when she first got to her feet that she was on a loser but she gave it her best shot for her client. She had almost certainly advised him to plead guilty and get a bit off his sentence but he wanted to carry on, so carry on she did.
That's what makes the Bar (and criminal defence solicitors) so special in my view.
The defendant was represented by a barrister and was what lawyers call (often with discreet smacking of the lips) a 'private payer' so the bill for solicitor and counsel was coming out of his own pocket.
Not to put too fine a point on it, his defence case was a crock of..... no, let decorum reign and let me say that it was not too strong. He had admitted enough to the arresting officers to guarantee his conviction before any bench that I can imagine, and just to make certain he had dotted all of the whatsits and crossed all of the doodahs in a taped interview. Nevertheless, Not Guilty was the plea, as is his right, and an attractive young barrister (yes, the attractive is irrelevant, but I am allowed to notice) made the best of a bad job. To make matters worse for the defence the relatively inexperienced Crown prosecutor had to be elsewhere at short notice so a barrister was drafted in from Chambers. As luck would have it the Chambers clerk had already despatched all of his young tyros so we got, thanks to the cab-rank rule, a fifty-ish brief who had obviously got a lot of legal mileage on his clock.
Following her client's instructions the defending counsel put forward his story, that was both implausible and legally hopeless. She had a polite go at the police officers' evidence, but I really started to admire her when her client went into the box and dug himself even deeper into the mire. She kept her composure, and her closing address to the court was properly researched, impeccable as to case law, and delivered with bright-eyed conviction.
Conviction is what her client got too.
I admire her because faced with one of the worst defence scenarios since the Little Big Horn she did a professional job and carried on fighting for her client until the inevitably bitter end. She knew when she first got to her feet that she was on a loser but she gave it her best shot for her client. She had almost certainly advised him to plead guilty and get a bit off his sentence but he wanted to carry on, so carry on she did.
That's what makes the Bar (and criminal defence solicitors) so special in my view.
Sunday, July 17, 2005
Disappointingly Prosaic
The rolling nineteenth-century prose of the Vagrancy Act 1824 made it an offence:-
to "willfully, openly, lewdly and obscenely expose the person with intent to insult any female". In a training handout that I was given years ago there was an asterisk against the word 'person' and a footnote that for the purpose of the Act 'person' meant 'penis'
This is the main offence committed by "flashers" - but note the necessity for there to be an intention to insult a female. This offence did not have to be committed in a public place. It was triable only by magistrates and carried three months imprisonment.
The Sexual Offences Act 2003 replaces these provisions with:-
66 Exposure
(1) A person commits an offence if-
(a) he intentionally exposes his genitals, and
(b) he intends that someone will see them and be caused alarm or distress.
(2) A person guilty of an offence under this section is liable-
(a) on summary conviction, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months or a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum or both;
(b) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 2 years.
Not only has the lovely old statute that we all knew by heart been replaced by a drab piece of Parliamentary draftsmanship, but the offence may now be sent to the Crown Court. In the lower court the penalty has doubled, and the maximum penalty has increased eightfold.
It won't make a ha'porth of difference though, since your stereotypical flasher is not one to make a fine calculation of the penalties before hauling out his person - oh, sorry, I meant penis.
to "willfully, openly, lewdly and obscenely expose the person with intent to insult any female". In a training handout that I was given years ago there was an asterisk against the word 'person' and a footnote that for the purpose of the Act 'person' meant 'penis'
This is the main offence committed by "flashers" - but note the necessity for there to be an intention to insult a female. This offence did not have to be committed in a public place. It was triable only by magistrates and carried three months imprisonment.
The Sexual Offences Act 2003 replaces these provisions with:-
66 Exposure
(1) A person commits an offence if-
(a) he intentionally exposes his genitals, and
(b) he intends that someone will see them and be caused alarm or distress.
(2) A person guilty of an offence under this section is liable-
(a) on summary conviction, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months or a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum or both;
(b) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 2 years.
Not only has the lovely old statute that we all knew by heart been replaced by a drab piece of Parliamentary draftsmanship, but the offence may now be sent to the Crown Court. In the lower court the penalty has doubled, and the maximum penalty has increased eightfold.
It won't make a ha'porth of difference though, since your stereotypical flasher is not one to make a fine calculation of the penalties before hauling out his person - oh, sorry, I meant penis.
Friday, July 15, 2005
Golden Minutes
I have just been reading the comments on my Trial and Error post and the issue of the Police caution has come up. When we are hearing a trial, I give especial weight to what was or was not said in the first five minutes after arrest. It is a deep human instinct to react indignantly when wrongly accused - just try telling a child off for something that he did not do, and see how you get on. To take a simple example, if a driver is breath tested in a pub car park but waits until his trial three months later to claim that he was just moving the car to park it safely before walking home, we are entitled to wonder why he did not say anything to the officers at the time.
On another topic, one of the questions that friends ask me most frequently is "What do you think of Judge John Deed?" Well it is complete tosh of course, and a real-life Deed would be out on his ear in no time, but it is enjoyable tosh. I lunched with a roomful of judges last year, and they were all eagerly discussing what Deed would be getting up to in that evening's episode. I think that the idea of a judge being sexy rather appeals to them, and they empathise with the idea of sinister and manipulative civil servants trying to keep the judge in order.
On another topic, one of the questions that friends ask me most frequently is "What do you think of Judge John Deed?" Well it is complete tosh of course, and a real-life Deed would be out on his ear in no time, but it is enjoyable tosh. I lunched with a roomful of judges last year, and they were all eagerly discussing what Deed would be getting up to in that evening's episode. I think that the idea of a judge being sexy rather appeals to them, and they empathise with the idea of sinister and manipulative civil servants trying to keep the judge in order.
Thursday, July 14, 2005
Confession
I felt truly uncomfortable at court today, and then I went and did something that I did not believe in, for the sake of appearances.
In the pre-court gathering of the magistrates who were on duty today a senior member of the court staff came and told us that he was awaiting guidance from Head Office about the approach to be taken to the two-minute silence in memory of last week's murder victims and about the exact wording of the tannoy announcement to be made. My immediate reaction was that the Courts Service could direct its staff as it pleased, but had no right to tell any member of the judiciary what to do. My second reaction was one of irritation that highly paid staff of Her Majesty's Court Service saw the need to direct a standard script to be used from Truro County Court to the Old Bailey. Surely this sort of thing would be far better left to local judgement.
It was news to me but most colleagues felt that we should all assemble outside the courthouse just before noon, in response to exhortations in the press and from Whitehall. I deplore this kind of Dianafication of our society, and my instinct was to have nothing to do with it. I feel that public display is entirely un-British, mawkish, and self-indulgent. It turned out that I was the only magistrate not to head for the door at noon, so at the last moment I went out to the front of the court and stood rather awkwardly between a policeman and an usher while assorted defendants and their supporters sat on the low wall smoking.
So why did I do it? I think that I was anxious not to appear to be criticising my colleagues by staying inside and having a coffee, but now I wish that I had stuck to my principles. The Chairman of the Bench was sitting today, and he said earlier in the morning that he felt it right for all courts to adjourn briefly just before 12 noon, and that magistrates should use their own judgement as to whether to go outside or not. But they all went, so I went along with them.
Now I feel rather grubby.
Nobody could feel more sympathy that I for the victims of the terrorists, but I abhor stage-managed demonstrations of sympathy that are directed more at the six o'clock news than at the murderous fanatics - who would be utterly unimpressed anyway.
In the pre-court gathering of the magistrates who were on duty today a senior member of the court staff came and told us that he was awaiting guidance from Head Office about the approach to be taken to the two-minute silence in memory of last week's murder victims and about the exact wording of the tannoy announcement to be made. My immediate reaction was that the Courts Service could direct its staff as it pleased, but had no right to tell any member of the judiciary what to do. My second reaction was one of irritation that highly paid staff of Her Majesty's Court Service saw the need to direct a standard script to be used from Truro County Court to the Old Bailey. Surely this sort of thing would be far better left to local judgement.
It was news to me but most colleagues felt that we should all assemble outside the courthouse just before noon, in response to exhortations in the press and from Whitehall. I deplore this kind of Dianafication of our society, and my instinct was to have nothing to do with it. I feel that public display is entirely un-British, mawkish, and self-indulgent. It turned out that I was the only magistrate not to head for the door at noon, so at the last moment I went out to the front of the court and stood rather awkwardly between a policeman and an usher while assorted defendants and their supporters sat on the low wall smoking.
So why did I do it? I think that I was anxious not to appear to be criticising my colleagues by staying inside and having a coffee, but now I wish that I had stuck to my principles. The Chairman of the Bench was sitting today, and he said earlier in the morning that he felt it right for all courts to adjourn briefly just before 12 noon, and that magistrates should use their own judgement as to whether to go outside or not. But they all went, so I went along with them.
Now I feel rather grubby.
Nobody could feel more sympathy that I for the victims of the terrorists, but I abhor stage-managed demonstrations of sympathy that are directed more at the six o'clock news than at the murderous fanatics - who would be utterly unimpressed anyway.
Tuesday, July 12, 2005
Trial and Error
When we sit on a trial, especially one that takes a few hours to hear, the whole pace of our work slows right down. Rather than the rapid-fire business of the remand court, when we might deal with 100 items of business in a day, or an afternoon spent sentencing cases that have had reports prepared, we have a chance to hear the whole of a case, from the prosecution’s opening statement to verdict and, if guilty, sentence.
When I first started hearing trials I was struck by the gentle unfolding of the story – after the prosecutor introduces the case everything looks straightforward, and then, one by one, the witnesses come forward, each with his or her piece of the jigsaw. What seems clear at the outset begins to take on unexpected nuances and angles. People tell us what they saw (or at least what they think they saw) and we take account of the way they give their evidence, and how they respond to cross-examination, that powerful tool that sometimes, with one question, snaps the light on in my head, and I can see: “Yes, that’s what happened”.
We are trained to consider evidence in a structured way, and we start by paring the case down to the agreed and the disputed facts. The agreed matters need not detain us, so we look at the crucial facts that will determine whether the Crown will prove its case. Where particular aspects of the law are involved the parties and our legal adviser will have given their opinions and advice in open court before we retire. We might be addressed on case law, on the elements of the offence, or on underlying principles such as the vital need to treat identification evidence with great caution. If I am part of a seasoned bench we might interrupt at the first mention of R v Turnbull, saying “We are familiar with the guidance in Turnbull, but if you wish to refresh our memory further, please do so”. Some advocates cannot take the hint, so our cup of tea, so essential to considering evidence, will have to wait a few more minutes.
Our task is to consider whether the Crown has proved its case Beyond Reasonable Doubt. That is not the same as deciding what really happened though. It is impossible to avoid forming your own idea of the true story, but we must keep that entirely separate from our verdict. The best place for it is in the post-court debrief between the bench and clerk.
A long time ago we heard a not-guilty plea to drink-driving. The defendant’s demeanour, not to mention his tie and the badge on his blazer, made it obvious that he was a former police officer. He was now employed as head of security at a large local business. The canteen lady had been found in possession of a part-used packet of bacon, and he had been sent for. Police were called. The two PCs who attended tried to persuade him not to press charges – the value of the stolen bacon was only a pound or two, and the lady would inevitably lose her job. He was adamant, quoting management orders, and the lady was duly arrested and taken to the police station. A couple of hours later the officers called from the station asking our man to go down to make a statement. He went about an hour later, made the statement, and spent a few minutes chatting about the old days when he had been in The Job. During the genial conversation it transpired that our former Sergeant had been to the Blue Lamp Club (the police sports and social club) earlier and had met a few old pals. He also casually mentioned that he had used the Old Pals’ Act to park in the Police Station car park.
Out of the blue, one of the PCs produced a breathalyser and asked him to take a breath test. He thought that it was a joke at first but he soon found out that it wasn’t. He failed, and was arrested and charged, which is how he ended up in court.
After the trial was over, we were sure that the full story was that the two young PCs had had quite enough of the old Sergeant’s patronising manner, and they were very unhappy about his pressing charges against the canteen lady. So they decided to teach him a lesson, on the basis that those who play everything by the book had better be careful to stay the right side of the law themselves.
The final twist in the tale is that we acquitted him. Once the officers formed a reasonable suspicion that he had been driving and that he had consumed alcohol, they had a duty under PACE to caution him before asking any further questions, and they didn’t. That made the arrest invalid, so off he went.
It’s better than the telly when that sort of thing happens.
When I first started hearing trials I was struck by the gentle unfolding of the story – after the prosecutor introduces the case everything looks straightforward, and then, one by one, the witnesses come forward, each with his or her piece of the jigsaw. What seems clear at the outset begins to take on unexpected nuances and angles. People tell us what they saw (or at least what they think they saw) and we take account of the way they give their evidence, and how they respond to cross-examination, that powerful tool that sometimes, with one question, snaps the light on in my head, and I can see: “Yes, that’s what happened”.
We are trained to consider evidence in a structured way, and we start by paring the case down to the agreed and the disputed facts. The agreed matters need not detain us, so we look at the crucial facts that will determine whether the Crown will prove its case. Where particular aspects of the law are involved the parties and our legal adviser will have given their opinions and advice in open court before we retire. We might be addressed on case law, on the elements of the offence, or on underlying principles such as the vital need to treat identification evidence with great caution. If I am part of a seasoned bench we might interrupt at the first mention of R v Turnbull, saying “We are familiar with the guidance in Turnbull, but if you wish to refresh our memory further, please do so”. Some advocates cannot take the hint, so our cup of tea, so essential to considering evidence, will have to wait a few more minutes.
Our task is to consider whether the Crown has proved its case Beyond Reasonable Doubt. That is not the same as deciding what really happened though. It is impossible to avoid forming your own idea of the true story, but we must keep that entirely separate from our verdict. The best place for it is in the post-court debrief between the bench and clerk.
A long time ago we heard a not-guilty plea to drink-driving. The defendant’s demeanour, not to mention his tie and the badge on his blazer, made it obvious that he was a former police officer. He was now employed as head of security at a large local business. The canteen lady had been found in possession of a part-used packet of bacon, and he had been sent for. Police were called. The two PCs who attended tried to persuade him not to press charges – the value of the stolen bacon was only a pound or two, and the lady would inevitably lose her job. He was adamant, quoting management orders, and the lady was duly arrested and taken to the police station. A couple of hours later the officers called from the station asking our man to go down to make a statement. He went about an hour later, made the statement, and spent a few minutes chatting about the old days when he had been in The Job. During the genial conversation it transpired that our former Sergeant had been to the Blue Lamp Club (the police sports and social club) earlier and had met a few old pals. He also casually mentioned that he had used the Old Pals’ Act to park in the Police Station car park.
Out of the blue, one of the PCs produced a breathalyser and asked him to take a breath test. He thought that it was a joke at first but he soon found out that it wasn’t. He failed, and was arrested and charged, which is how he ended up in court.
After the trial was over, we were sure that the full story was that the two young PCs had had quite enough of the old Sergeant’s patronising manner, and they were very unhappy about his pressing charges against the canteen lady. So they decided to teach him a lesson, on the basis that those who play everything by the book had better be careful to stay the right side of the law themselves.
The final twist in the tale is that we acquitted him. Once the officers formed a reasonable suspicion that he had been driving and that he had consumed alcohol, they had a duty under PACE to caution him before asking any further questions, and they didn’t. That made the arrest invalid, so off he went.
It’s better than the telly when that sort of thing happens.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)